Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations
Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations

The First Step Toward World Peace? Fix the UN

3m read
At the United Nations Security Council, on Oct. 25, 2023, members voted on two draft texts about the Mideast, each focusing on the Israel-Hamas war. Both failed to be adopted, including the one submitted by Russia, above. The essayist, a former Canadian diplomat at the UN, suggests that in light of the Council’s “glaring inaction” on the war, the General Assembly must pass an “existential” resolution that gives it precedence over the Council “in times of conflict.” JOHN PENNEY/PASSBLUE

The saddest part of the spectacle of three competing United Nations Security Council resolutions on the Israel-Hamas conflict all failing in the last few weeks is that it was classic Council intractability and, as such, not a surprise.

The inability of the Council to uphold and apply the UN Charter is all too familiar. Decades of gridlock and self-interest on the part of certain members of the P5 (Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States) were capped in 2022, when Russia, the aggressor, was able to veto Ukraine-related resolutions.

That crisis could have been a turning point. A moment of reckoning for the UN. An “enough is enough” catalytic opportunity for most of the 193 to put their collective feet down.

The UN Charter provided the tool to do so in Article 27 (3), which states that a party to a dispute in the Council (including both permanent and elected members) shall abstain from voting in decisions under Chapter VI of the Charter. In fact, in the first six years of the UN — between 1946 and 1952 — Council members regularly adhered to the obligatory abstention rule. Members that voluntarily abstained during this period included the UK, France, India and Pakistan.


Alas, over time, the P5 have curtailed the application of this mechanism. While there were private conversations about invoking Article 27 (3) over Russia’s behavior in Ukraine, none of the 10 elected members had the courage, vision or backing to put forward a resolution. One can only assume that the other veto-wielding powers — the US, UK, France and China — had zero interest in supporting such a move for fear it would limit their own power in the future.

According to the Security Council Report, an independent organization, in May, 2023: “The non-application of Article 27 (3) in this (Ukrainian) case could fuel arguments that there has been a normative evolution in the practice and that a new customary rule has developed. By remaining silent, Council members may be reinforcing the idea that Article 27(3) is no longer relevant.”

Time and time again, the anachronistic P5 have worked to solidly increase their power beyond the original intent in 1945. They have manipulated, changed and imposed rules and procedures not to uphold the values of the UN or prevent conflict but to game the system to their advantage.

And other member states have let them get away with it.

In the face of widespread public outrage over the lack of fortitude on the part of the Council to take a stand over Russia’s blatant aggression against Ukraine, many member states acted and called for a Special Emergency Session of the General Assembly over the conflict. It later passed a resolution to hold P5 members who used the veto to account, at least symbolically. But this was a mere Band-Aid on what has been a hemorrhage of credibility for the UN. And Russia simply shrugged its shoulders and kept on defying international law by targeting and killing civilians.

Fast-forward to the current crisis in the Middle East. Yet again, just weeks into the conflict, the Council has failed to agree on the most minimum standard of protecting civilians. Not just one or two, but a total of four P5 members have used their veto at one time or another these past few weeks, France being the exception.

In light of this mess, yet again, the General Assembly called for a Emergency Special Session. A resolution calling for peace was presented by Jordan for a vote. It passed last week with overwhelming support.

I would argue that the General Assembly needs to pass an existential resolution: one that gives it precedence over the Council in times of conflict so that all countries who wish to can speak as equal members in the Assembly and not as an afterthought to glaring inaction on the part of the Council. This way, each member state can speak, not as invited nonvoting presenters in the undemocratic, cynical club that is the Security Council but as equal nations.

Such a resolution should stipulate that the Assembly can instruct the Council to take action to protect civilian life. This is possible. But it takes conviction.

The will of the two-thirds majority of the Assembly is as close as you can get to fairness, legitimacy and the values that underpin the UN. I have rarely seen that majority act immorally. It is the ultimate protection against the self-dealing and gamesmanship of the Council.

Time to use it. Who has the courage to lead the way? The world is waiting.

Otherwise, we can expect the reputation and efficacy of the entire UN to deteriorate further and the cycle of violence and suffering to continue in the Middle East. Because under the status quo, there will be no binding resolutions to prevent further deaths in Israel or Gaza. All we can still hope for is that diplomacy through other channels will somehow prevail down the road.

An earlier version of this essay appeared in Policy Magazine.
Related Posts
Louise Blais

Policy contributing writer Louise Blais served as Canada's ambassador to the United Nations and as consul general in Atlanta. She is now an adviser to the Pendleton Group and diplomat in residence at Laval University in Quebec City.

We would love your thoughts. Please comment:

The First Step Toward World Peace? Fix the UN
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

8 Comments
zdenek s.
zdenek s.
3 years ago

The Security Council vote is a visible and often criticized example of UN dysfunction, but in reality it is a proxy problem. The Security Council can agree on a resolution – and what next? If there is no ability and will to enforce it, it is just a piece of paper.
Hypothetically – the UN Security Council calls for a halt to Israeli operations in Gaza and Israel disobeys – what next? Will the US push for a resolution even at the cost of a confrontation with the IDF? Undoubtedly not. Or will the UN Security Council condemn Russia’s attack on Ukraine, will the US engage in war even at the cost of nuclear war? Also no.
So how will a possible P5 agreement actually help civilians in Gaza or Ukraine? In fact, nothing at all.

Gail G.
3 years ago

I totally agree with the above article. The UN definitely needs to be fixed perhaps in the way suggested above. I’m deeply concerned, as a long-time supporter of the UN and many years on the Board of Directors of the Santa Barbara Tri-Counties Chapter of the UNA-USA, that the UN has failed in its prime reason for existence to be the world’s peacekeeper (rather than the U.S. trying to do that). Thus, the UN is losing its status in the world’s eye.

Georgia
Georgia
3 years ago

A “forgotten peace formula” (Franz Jedlicka) seems to be to reduce violence against children in the families, because there seems to be a linkage between a culture of violence that starts already in the families of a country and armed conflict. This is true for Russia as well as for Palestine according UNICEF data and child corporal punishment laws. The same relation can be found with a high level of domestic violence against women (Valerie Hudson). Policital efforts are short term strategies, but they might not help if violence is widely accepted in societal areas in a country.

Georgios Kostakos
3 years ago

A proposal worth considering, that of the UN General Assembly asserting its supremacy over the Security Council and asking the latter to take decisions within certain parametres, to operationalize the Council’s mandate and that of the UN as a whole. Unfortunately, there is no courage to point, similarly to the illegal Russian invasion of Ukraine, to the mistakes and trespasses of the West, including the illegal invasion of Iraq by the US in 2003, as well as the frequent use of the US veto to shield Israel from any consequences of its blatant disrespect for the rights of the Palestinian people. The author is right that the two-thirds majority of the General Assembly is by far closer to what is right morally and according to the UN Charter than any single state or small groups of states claiming to speak for “the international community”. That is also true, though, when that majority criticizes the North for not keeping its commitments on development assistance, not providing the promised climate finance, not regulating the global financial system that leads to heavy indebtedness and skyrocketing inequalities, etc. The first step to world peace is objectivity, acceptance of real equality and of the importance of the interests/rights/responsibilities of everybody. What we need is a UN that works for all without bias in favour of the strong and well-entrenched, whatever ideology they may proclaim and whatever image they may have been cultivating for themselves.

Abdelhamid Siyam
Abdelhamid Siyam
3 years ago

I strongly object to label what is going on now in Gaza as Israeli-HAMAS war. First, It is not a war. War occurs between two equal or semi-equal parties. This a geocidal war against the occupied Palestinian people at large. Look at the volume of the victims in Gaza, the majority are children, women, humanitarian workers, UN staff, hospitals, schools, mosques, churches, UNRWA schools, First aid workers and vehicles. In addition, look what is happening in the occupied West Bank where there is no HAMAS. What do you call that? It is appalling to label these relentless bombardment as a war between Israel and HAMAS.

Kirk Boyd
3 years ago

Important article. Thank you. What do you propose is the legal mechanism for a judicial decision on whether there has be a violation of 27(3)?
Kirk Boyd, Executive Director, Legal Pact for the Future

Alexander POLLOCK
Alexander POLLOCK
3 years ago

While I agree with much that is stated in his article, the question of Ukraine is biased and takes a one-sided view of Russian invasion that was largely the result of the continuing expansion of NATO into Eastern Europe and the Balkans, contrary to agreement not to do so. This is the primary cause of the Russian invasion. It is hypocritical that the western nations who are against Russian occupation in parts of Ukraine are unwilling to speak up about the 56 year long occupation by Israel of the Palestinian Territories or push to enact a truly just resolution of this conflict for both Palestinians and Israelis, with the conflict remaining frozen in a Schmittian gridlock of “friends versus enemies”. As long as this situation continues, the UN is unlikely to find a way to provide a means to contribute to a meaningful resolution or process for ether conflict other than moral humanism.

Dr Bilali Camara
Dr Bilali Camara
3 years ago

The UN was a failure at its conception because France, the loser of WWII, was admitted among the P5 because of its then colonial power on Africa as if colonies will belong to France forever! A very serious lack of understanding of humans’ aspirations to liberty, self determination and freedom!

Listen to \'The World\'s Toughest Job\' podcast

MOST POPULAR

1
Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations
Global Connections Television - The only talk show of its kind in the world

Understand the changing UN

 

Get PassBlue's award-winning reporting on the UN and global affairs.

Close the CTA