
The far-right and right-wing populists have quickly gained ground in the West, securing historic wins in elections in France, Portugal, the European Union and the United Kingdom in the last months. Meanwhile, hard-right forces are already in power in Italy, Slovakia, Finland, Hungary, the Netherlands and the Czech Republic. Austria and the United States could very well join these ranks by the end of the year.
With geopolitical tensions at an all-time high, conflicts and humanitarian crises escalating and an international system struggling to cope, what does it mean for the United Nations and the multilateral order it represents if nationalist right-wingers are calling the shots?
Multilateralism à la carte
The prospects of former President Donald Trump regaining the White House in November have given way to much speculation about what he might do with a second term. When it comes to the UN, his campaign has hinted at a faithful return to his past approach, with a draft executive order to withdraw again from the Paris climate deal waiting to be signed on his first day in office, according to Politico.
His political supporters have vowed that Trump would also quit once more the World Health Organization and the ongoing pandemic treaty talks, which they believe undermine US interests and sovereignty.
Should we expect similar hostility from other right-wing populist governments towards multilateralism? From climate skepticism to xenophobia and nationalism, the far right’s views often clash with the universal values upheld by the UN. Some hardliners single out the international body, including suggesting leaving it altogether. But in practical terms, the far right’s relation to multilateralism and the UN is far more complex than their discourse suggests.
According to Laura Bullon-Cassis, a postdoctoral researcher at the Albert Hirschman Centre on Democracy at the Graduate Institute, far-right groups tend to engage in “multilateralism a la carte.”
“Instead of adhering to the global rule-based order, [they are] rather picking and choosing what they’re O.K. with and making it conditional,” she said.
The French National Rally’s far-right leader Marine Le Pen, who stands to be one of the major contenders during presidential elections in 2027, has assured she would uphold the Paris climate deal as long as it didn’t interfere with France’s sovereignty and economic growth.
Hard-right-wingers have also been generally in favor of strengthening cooperation at the EU and global level when it aligns with their priorities, for instance, on security.
For Bullon-Cassis, this points to a more insidious relationship these parties have with the UN, contrasting with Trump’s adversarial stance. She cited Giorgia Meloni’s speech at the UN General Assembly in September 2023, where the right-wing populist Italian prime minister blamed migrant deaths in the Mediterranean Sea on smugglers and called on the UN to “wage a global war without mercy against traffickers of human beings.”
“[Meloni] went to the UN to secure international support on migration, because discussions within the EU are at a stalemate,” Bullon-Cassis said. “So she bypassed the EU and turned to the UN for her own goals, which are, in fact, very nationalistic . . . and promote Christian, European values. She has said that she doesn’t want Italy to be turned into Europe’s refugee camps.”
Similarly, Le Pen proposed last year a declaration on the rights of nations to preserve their identity from the influence of international institutions and multinational firms, as a “complement” to the UN Declaration on Human Rights.
Could these ideas appeal to other governments and take root at the UN? Bullon-Cassis notes that unlike the EU, which has protective mechanisms against extremes, the world body is sorely lacking in that department. “The UN is more vulnerable to alliances like powerful coalitions that can be either unconstructive or use those platforms and agreements for their own gains,” she said.
Migration: the core of the struggle
The fact that the issue of migration is at the core of these nationalists’ agenda is no coincidence. Their rise can be traced to the 1980s when European nations negotiated free circulation in the Schengen area and the opening of borders, which were perceived as an “attack to national identity” by these movements, said Sandro Cattacin, a sociology professor at the University of Geneva.
“This was the beginning of the question, ‘Do we want globalization, or do we want the old protectionist world, where states are very strong and have control over global dynamics?'” the expert said, noting that this also gave rise to left populists who also contested the global economic order. The financial crisis of 2008 and the austerity measures put in place to redress the economy later allowed populists to consolidate support within struggling communities.
Now many of what started out as extreme-right parties rooted in ultranationalist ideology, racism and antisemitism have learned to adapt, moving closer to populism, according to Cattacin, with programs that are constantly changing and responding to grievances left unattended by others in power.
But restricting migration remains one of their raisons d’être in a context where Europe has struggled to agree on a policy to address the issue of irregular migration. Already in 2018, nationalist groups could be seen coalescing around this issue at talks for a global compact on migration, with the US President Trump, Hungary’s Viktor Orban, Austrian Chancellor Sebastian Kurz, Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis, Italian Prime Minister Matteo Salvini as well as Poland under the Law and Justice party rejecting the nonbinding agreement using the argument that it would undermine security and open the doors to undocumented migrants.
In the recent elections in the EU and France, the thorny issue took center stage, with far-right groups depicting it as a threat and offering tighter border controls and reduced protections for migrants and asylum seekers as a solution.
The UN high commissioner for human rights, Volker Turk, pointed last month to the rise in hate speech that arose from political debates about migration. “We need to be very vigilant because especially history tells us, in particular in Europe, that the vilification of the other, that the denigration of the other, is a harbinger for what’s to come,” he said.
Despite the inflammatory rhetoric, Cattacin tempers fears about the scale of the far-right’s impact on UN affairs. “It’s perhaps the principle of reality. When you have to decide and govern, there are more important things than strong positions,” he said.
As an example, the policies of the Trump presidency’s Muslim ban were more symbolic than leading to a profound reshaping of the multilateral order. “That’s not hard economics, that’s not even hard politics. When it comes to the core of the international economic and political dynamics, these parties follow because there’s no alternative,” Cattacin said.
High stakes on the horizon
But as an adviser for former President Barack Obama pointed out in the magazine Foreign Affairs, the stakes in the upcoming US elections are much higher. Volatile dynamics in the Middle East could also take a turn for the worse if Trump ramps up tensions with Iran after exiting the nuclear deal in 2018. Disregard for international law is rife in wars in Ukraine, Gaza, Sudan and elsewhere, as it is for global institutions that dare to meddle.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) is a case in point: US politicians have threatened it with sanctions for going after Benjamin Netanyahu and other Israeli leaders for alleged war crimes in Gaza, while Hungary has said it would dismiss the ICC arrest warrant against Russian President Vladimir Putin. As the UN grapples with an unprecedented budgetary deficit, potential cuts in aid programs would also hurt its activities, especially in cases where these are politically driven, like the suspension this year of US funds to the UN Palestinian aid agency, Unrwa, until 2025 or Trump’s suspension of funds to the UN Population Fund during his presidency over its sexual and reproductive health operations.
Multilateral processes such as current negotiations for a plastic pollution treaty or the yearly climate summits where countries agree on how to globally tackle the climate crisis also stand to be affected. Bullon-Cassis, who took part in UN negotiations when working with the International Institute for Sustainable Development, remembers what it was like to have a US delegation under Trump in the room. “They had a profoundly unconstructive approach, saying things that were either blocking the negotiations or being dismissive, like leaving a negotiation early and making a spectacle out of it,” she recalled.
“A presidency is a long time when you think about the urgency of the climate and environmental crises.”
Despite this, Cattacin doesn’t think the far-right’s winning streak will last. “Like in the 70s, we are in a period of social change, with movements for peace and the ecological crisis driven by very young people,” he said. “I expect that we will have a completely different political landscape in some years than these reactions of the old against the new world.”
This article was published courtesy of Geneva Solutions under Creative Commons license.








The UN should be more worried about the influence of the progressive left on the UN agenda. An organisation that was founded to avert future wars that pays more attention to gender, climate, race and sexual orientation today is untrustworthy.
For everyone, not just the extreme right. How important the UN is for Canada, for example (Trudeau is not a populist) shows the fulfillment of the QRF promise from the Vancouver ministerial.
Disappointed to read that only countries in the North are mentioned
Is this Pass North? The far tight else where does not concern “the UN”?
Have you heard of former President Bolsonaro, of Milei, of Modi, just to mention a few?
Please Pass Blue… I usually appreciate your publications
Far rights leaders are very much uneducated about migration a genetic human behaviour and often like Donald Trump they forget that they themselves are products of a migration. They may dream of building a wall but as the Berlin wall any wall will fall down one day. The best option is to work together as one world and manage migration because we need each other. The actual configuration of the world between poor and rich countries is not sustainable and will fall down one day as new configurations will emerge.