Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations
Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations

As Israel’s UNRWA Ban Kicks In, the UN Boss Must Be Ready for Day After

Gazans pick up humanitarian aid amid the Hamas-Israel ceasefire
Israel’s ban of UNRWA operations is to take effect Jan. 30, violating international law. As part of the ban, Israel is demanding that the UN agency, which supports Palestinian refugees in the occupied Palestinian territory, evacuate its headquarters in East Jerusalem. The essayists, former UNRWA officials, offer advice to the UN secretary-general on how he can immediately stop the takeover of the agency’s base. Here, Gazans pick up humanitarian aid amid the Hamas-Israel ceasefire. UNRWA/IG

In his latest affront to the United Nations system and international law, Israel’s UN ambassador wrote to Secretary-General António Guterres on Jan. 24, saying that UNRWA “must cease its operations in Jerusalem, and evacuate all premises in which it operates in the city, no later than 30 January 2025.”

The move is part of Israel’s illegal ban of UNRWA, the UN’s Palestinian refugee agency, as it is about to enter into force, triggering wide-ranging measures aimed at ending the organization’s operations in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, including East Jerusalem.

We call on Guterres to reject Israel’s demand and take immediate steps to prevent UNRWA’s East Jerusalem headquarters from being taken over by Israel. The secretary-general should also direct the UN Refugee Agency, UNHCR, to lead and coordinate the response to the void left from the UNRWA ban.


While the exact effects of the ban are difficult to predict, given the different areas and sectors in which UNRWA works, it will create dire consequences for Palestinians living in the occupied Palestinian territory (OPT). The most immediate change will be felt in East Jerusalem, where UNRWA will be completely banned, while the worst results will be experienced in Gaza, most likely endangering the massively stepped-up relief operation now underway since the start of the ceasefire between Hamas and Israel.

The UN’s official position in response to the Israeli ban has been one of wait-and-see. Guterres instructed UNRWA and the greater UN family operating in the OPT not to do any contingency planning, as that would imply an acceptance of Israeli laws. They were passed by the Knesset three months ago, but they are deemed illegal according to international law.

Meanwhile, heavy pressure from Washington is being applied to other UN agencies, such as the World Food Program and the International Organization for Migration, to prepare to take over UNRWA operations in Gaza. Israel has also begun conversations with key UN agencies in Gaza.

While UNRWA’s top official, Philippe Lazzarini, says that the agency is receiving little information from Israeli officials on how the ban will be carried out, other humanitarian agencies must walk a tightrope to be prepared for what lies ahead while heeding Guterres’s instructions not to plan anything.

This contradictory approach has led to what one senior UN official described as “a train crash waiting to happen.” The suffering of the Palestinian population, particularly in Gaza, will increase dramatically as UNRWA, the backbone of the humanitarian operation, crumbles without an alternative structure in place. The educational and health sector in the West Bank will also fall into dire straits, with no viable alternatives available.

As part of Israel’s expulsion of UNRWA from its East Jerusalem headquarters on Jan. 30, the government will most likely confiscate the agency’s buildings and transform the site into a Jewish settlement, blatantly violating international law. This move will further consolidate Israel’s illegal annexation of East Jerusalem and represents a further nail in the coffin of the remnants of the peace process toward a two-state solution.

But, as one UN official put it, “now begins the septic effects of this self-inflicted wound on the state of Israel, blindly removing a key instrument of stability in Palestinian communities across the region. They will likely pay a heavy price ultimately.”

At this 11th hour, we call on Guterres to prevent Israel from unilaterally kicking out a UN agency from its territory. He can do this easily by turning the UNRWA compound in East Jerusalem into a space shared by all the UN agencies operating in the OPT, providing a base from which to enhance their work as part of the Gaza ceasefire and flooding the Strip with humanitarian essentials.

In addition, Guterres should push another urgently needed response to the UNRWA ban. As Israel is a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention, a cessation of UNRWA operations in Israeli territory will trigger the application of Article 1D2 of the Convention in all territory where it exercises effective control — that is, the entirety of the OPT, including East Jerusalem — thus automatically entitling the refugees to the benefits of the Convention.

Similarly, banning UNRWA triggers the responsibility of the UN Refugee Agency, or UNHCR. This does not mean that it must take over or replace the services that UNRWA has provided, given that its mandate toward refugees worldwide is starkly different than UNRWA’s. However, with UNRWA unable to assist Palestinian refugees in the OPT, it will become the Refugee Agency’s role to lead and coordinate the response to the new reality in the region.

UNHCR’s involvement will enable it to use its toolbox for addressing massive refugee situations, including protracted ones, as set out in its statute, the New York Declaration on Refugees and Migrants and the Global Compact on Refugees. That includes the potential development of a Comprehensive Refugee Response Framework as a response to the current crisis.

Furthermore, the involvement of the Refugee Agency will enhance protection and overcome the solutions gap faced by Palestinian refugees, currently the only group of forcibly displaced people without an institution to help them end their plight as refugees.

Accordingly, we urge Guterres to instruct Filippo Grandi, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees and a former Commissioner-General of UNRWA, to provide reassurances to the Palestinian refugees that as new “persons of concern to UNHCR” they will continue to be adequately supported by the UN.

Related Posts
Christopher Gunness

Chris Gunness is director of the UK-based Myanmar Accountability Project and has been reporting on Myanmar since the 1980s. Additionally, he was UNRWA’s Director of Communications from 2007 to 2020.

 

Lex Takkenberg is senior adviser for the Arab Renaissance for Democracy and Development and a former UNRWA director.

 

We would love your thoughts. Please comment:

As Israel’s UNRWA Ban Kicks In, the UN Boss Must Be Ready for Day After
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Farhang Jahanpour
1 year ago

The world is at a crossroads. It is either the rule of international law represented by the United Nations and its Charter or the Israeli violation of international order.

Israel which owes its existence to a United Nations General Assembly resolution (with much fewer votes than the votes of the same body for a Palestinian state) is kicking the UN in the teeth and orders it to violate international law. Israel has declared the UN Secretary-General “persona non grata”, it has violated both the rulings of the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court and is now ordering the UN to dismantle UNRWA.

This is a decision taken by a rogue, genocidal state but it cannot overrule numerous UN resolutions recognizing a Palestinian state. Last year, the UN General Assembly, with 172 votes for and only 4 votes against and 10 abstentions, called for the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination to be respected.

If we believe in international law and a future based on legality and the UN Charter, Israel must be forced to end its illegal occupation of Palestinian territories and allow the Palestinians to live free and independent lives. It is not for an occupying regime to tell the United Nations what it should and should not do in the Palestinian state.

Dr Bilali Camara
Dr Bilali Camara
1 year ago

Chris and Lex are Palestinians becoming refugees on their own lands? We do not see any role of UNHCR or any other UN agency but the UNRWA in this situation of genocide in Palestina. Furthermore, the UN does not belong to Israel and its annexation of Palestinian lands in Gaza and the West bank cannot be recognised by the United Nations.

Chris Gunness
Chris Gunness
1 year ago

Hello Dr Bilali, thank you for your message. I agree that the annexation of Palestine cannot be recognized. What suggestions do you have, given that Israel has banned UNRWA from Palestine and holds the guns? Of course the law is not on Israel’s side, but the Jewish state seems not to care about becoming a pariah state, just like apartheid South Africa.

Herzel Ashkenazi
Herzel Ashkenazi
1 year ago

How come you did not address the fact that UNRWA employees participated in the October 7 massacre of Jews? How come you didn’t mention that UNRWA is the only UN refugee agency that lasted over 75 years? How about the UNRAW education of Palestinians that promotes violence and hatred of Jews? If your opinion included comments on the need to reform UNRWA, kick out its failed leadership, and punish those who participated in the October 7 massacre of Jews, it would have made it more palatable.

Chris Gunness
Chris Gunness
1 year ago

Dear Herzel Ashkenazi, thank you for your comment. As several UN officials have pointed out, including the new head of UN OCHA, Tom Fletcher, Israel has produced no evidence to back up its claims that UNRWA staff took part in the October 2023 attack. The independent investigation by the former French FM, Colonna, also said Israel produced no evidence. Israel and its supporters are full of allegations, but no proven evidence. If there was evidence against UNRWA staff, UNRWA’s textbooks, UNRWA teachers etc, the Colonna report was a once in a lifetime opportunity for Israel and its supporters to produce it. They did not. Enough said.

Peter Gross
Peter Gross
1 year ago

Mr. Ashkenazi’s points are dead on. Furthermore, when an agency like the UNRWA is infiltrated by terrorists and perhaps even directly complicit in Hamas and Islamic Jihad’s “activities,” the idea that Israel’s ban is illegal, becomes an ugly comedy routine. A hypocritical, criminal comedy routine.

Listen to \'The World\'s Toughest Job\' podcast

MOST POPULAR

1
Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations
Global Connections Television - The only talk show of its kind in the world

Understand the changing UN

 

Get PassBlue's award-winning reporting on the UN and global affairs.

Close the CTA