Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations
Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations

The European Union Official Promoting a Parallel ‘Board of Peace’

4m read
Dubravka Suica, right, Europe’s Commissioner for the Mediterranean, with Prime Minister Mohammed Mustafa of the Palestinian Authority, briefing media on July 13, 2026, about new funding for the Palestine Donor Group, which is focusing on postwar Gaza reconstruction, putting it in possible competitition with the US-led Board of Peace. © European Union, 2026, licensed under CC BY 4.0.

Dubravka Suica’s appointment in 2024 as Europe’s first Commissioner for the Mediterranean has propelled her into a high-profile post, co-leading the Palestine Donor Group, which is weaving its way around US President Trump’s flailing Board of Peace and could become a rival if the board collapses.

At the second meeting of the Palestine Donor Group (PDG) in July, which focused on postwar plans for Gaza, Suica referred to the efforts as “our board of peace” and was adamant in marking out a distinct path for its efforts but is still inviting controversy in the European Union by forging diplomatic connections with the US Board of Peace (BoP). Its work is backed by a November 2025 United Nations Security Council resolution enshrining President Trump’s 21-point peace plan.

Suica co-chairs the PDG with Prime Minister Mohammed Mustafa of the Palestinian Authority, or PA. The group was formed in late 2025 as part of the EU’s Program for Palestinian Recovery and Resilience and announced support of about $1.8 billion for the authority in the West Bank and Gaza in April that year. With $35 billion mobilized since 1994, Europe says it is the largest global donor to the PA.


The EU’s history of support to the authority and rapid build-up of funding to Gaza — where the Board of Peace is struggling to get financing commitments — raises possible tensions between the two efforts, creating a narrow path for Suica to navigate between the US, which aims to be seen in the lead, and the European Union, which does not wholly approve of the US plans.

At the Palestine Donor Group conference in July, Suica did secure the remote participation of a key Trump envoy, Jared Kushner; as well as in-person participation by the high representative for the board, Nickolay Mladenov, and Ali Shaath, who leads its National Committee for the Administration of Gaza, or NCAG. 

“We wanted to have all of them on board,” Suica said to the press after the conference, “because we see that we have to work together.” 

But the EU does not unanimously support engagement with the BoP. European members of the Security Council voted in favor of the resolution in November backing the board, but the EU also expressed strong concerns about transparency and inclusivity in the board’s set-up. Although 14 EU countries attended the board’s first meeting in February 2026 as observers, some pointed out the constitutional incompatibility of fully joining an international body that puts one leader of one country, Trump, in power for life.

Opposition to Suica’s own attendance at the BoP meeting came mostly from a coalition of the European Parliament’s left-leaning parties, who sent a letter to the European Commission’s president, Ursula von der Leyen, calling the move “a grave error of judgement” and protested the appearance of endorsement by the EU that Suica’s presence as a commissioner may give. Suica is part of the center-right European People’s party that has dominated EU political bodies for decades.

US response

The main agenda of the July PDG meeting, held in Brussels, was the announcement of the Team Gaza Initiative, intended to complement the Security Council resolution endorsing Trump’s Board of Peace, and other international efforts to back early-recovery plans in Gaza. The meeting brought pledges totaling approximately $1 billion toward this work.

The PDG and the US board plans for Gaza bear critical differences. For one, Suica declared that infrastructure projects should begin even if the Israeli-Hamas ceasefire was still shaky and Hamas had yet to give up its weapons.

“Gaza’s early recovery cannot wait until every political question is resolved,” Suica said in Brussels. “The people of Gaza need our support now.”

The US plan, however, sets conditions for releasing financial support and is bogged down with Israel’s refusal to follow the outlined steps to Gaza’s postwar recovery. The US envisages phased progress, but Israel insists that Hamas lay down all its weapons before reconstruction begins. This impasse threatens the viability of Trump’s peace plan and the Board of Peace.

And in remarks delivered on July 28 at a Security Council briefing on the Mideast, Ambassador Tammy Bruce — a deputy representative of the US to the UN — acknowledged the Palestine Donor Group but asserted that its efforts “must be carried out in close coordination with the NCAG and the Board of Peace.”

There is also strong disagreement regarding the future of UNRWA, the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine refugees.  “We know that UNRWA has no place in Gaza,” Bruce added. Nor is there any role for Hamas in the region’s political future. “We have been clear about that as well.”

But the EU consistently declares its support for UNRWA, including in the PDG’s press statement after its first meeting last November. Asked recently for confirmation about UNRWA support, the European Commission’s spokesperson said: “As reiterated by the leaders, and in several European councils, the EU stands in support to [UNRWA’s] mission, which provides critical and essential services to the civilian population both in Gaza, the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and in the wider region.”

Suica has not made herself available for media interviews, even for background information.

Mohammed Mustafa, the co-chair of the PDG, has been prime minister of Palestine since 2024 and led a rebuilding project in Gaza after the 50-day war that Israel waged in the territory in 2014. He spent 15 years at the World Bank, and has been chair and co-president of the Palestinian Investment Fund — a key funding mechanism of the PA — since 2009.

Besides her role in the PDG, Suica’s Mediterranean portfolio is expansive, with Turkey and Syria also in her sights, but the US war in Iran adds complications to her agenda in the broader region.

Suica has been a member of the European Commission since 2019, following three terms in the European Parliament; her first term began in 2013, when Croatia, her country, joined the EU.

Before that, she was mayor of Dubrovnik, from 2001 to 2009, and a member of the Croatian parliament for the center-right Croatian Democratic Union (HDZ). In her EU roles, she is attached to the European People’s Party, which also skews center-right and has dominated the European Parliament since 1999.

Suica is no stranger to conflict. She was in her 30s when the Croatian war of independence broke out; Dubrovnik was under siege for eight months in 1991-1992.

In the lead-up to Suica’s appointment to the European Commission in 2019, the EU Observer, a news site, reported concerns about her voting record as a member of the European Parliament on issues involving women’s reproductive freedom, where she attempted to block references to provision of contraceptives and abortion care in motions she proposed.

The EC spokesperson said no date had been set for the next meeting of the Palestine Donor Group.

Related Posts
Maria Luisa Gambale

Maria Luisa Gambale, a graduate of Harvard University, lives in New York City. In addition to writing, she produces film and media projects and is director of the 2011 film "Sarabah," about the Senegalese rapper-activist Sister Fa. She has produced and directed video for National Geographic, ABC News, The New York Times and Fusion Network. Gambale's work in all media can be viewed at www.veradonnafilms.com.

We would love your thoughts. Please comment:

The European Union Official Promoting a Parallel ‘Board of Peace’
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Ambassador Cecilia McGill
Ambassador Cecilia McGill
2 months ago

Two “Boards of Peace”? What the European Initiative Says About the Future of Multilateral Diplomacy

The emergence of a European initiative described as a parallel “Board of Peace” raises a larger question than the future of Gaza: What should international peacebuilding look like in an increasingly transactional world?

The initiative, associated with European efforts to coordinate support for Gaza’s reconstruction and future, deserves serious attention. Not because the world needs another competing institution, but because it presents an opportunity to reconsider how peace, reconstruction and international responsibility should be organized.

President Donald Trump’s Board of Peace has generated considerable international interest, but also questions about its structure, membership, financing, representation and relationship with established multilateral institutions. The reported requirement that permanent members contribute $1 billion raises an uncomfortable question: Should a country’s ability to pay determine its influence in an international peace initiative?

Financial resources are undoubtedly essential. Gaza’s reconstruction will require enormous investments, and international donors will have to shoulder a substantial burden. But there is a fundamental distinction between financing peace and purchasing influence in the architecture of peace.

Peace cannot become a commodity.

This is where the emerging European approach could provide an important alternative — if it is constructed around genuine multilateral cooperation rather than becoming another parallel power structure.

Europe has an opportunity to bring together European governments, Arab states, international financial institutions, Palestinians and other relevant stakeholders, while working closely with the United Nations. Such an approach could combine financial capacity with diplomatic experience, regional knowledge and institutional legitimacy.

But there is a danger here as well.

The international community does not need two competing “Boards of Peace,” each claiming to provide the answer to Gaza. Institutional competition should not become a substitute for political solutions.

The United Nations, despite its weaknesses and profound political divisions, remains the principal universal institution created to address international peace and security. Its shortcomings should lead to reform and greater effectiveness — not to its marginalization.

The European initiative could therefore become an important test of whether multilateral diplomacy can still adapt to new realities.

But credibility will depend on results.

The international community has witnessed countless conferences, donor meetings, declarations and diplomatic initiatives that produced commitments on paper but insufficient change on the ground. What is required now is real, robust commitment — not simply diplomatic travel from one meeting to another without measurable outcomes.

The negotiators must have the experience, regional knowledge, cultural understanding and negotiation skills necessary to deal with the extraordinary complexity of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. They must also have the political independence to negotiate for peace rather than for personal, political or financial interests.

And Palestinians must not merely be recipients of decisions made elsewhere. They must have a meaningful role in determining the political and economic future of their own society.

This is perhaps the most important distinction between a genuinely multilateral peace framework and a transactional one.

Who pays matters. But who has a voice matters even more.

International financing should be welcomed. Arab and European leadership should be welcomed. American engagement should be welcomed. UN involvement should be welcomed. But none of these should substitute for the fundamental principles of inclusive diplomacy, accountability, international law and political ownership.

The question, therefore, should not be which “Board of Peace” prevails.

The question should be:

Which framework can actually deliver peace, security, reconstruction, dignity and hope to the people of Gaza — and help establish the conditions for a sustainable political settlement?

If the European initiative can demonstrate that peacebuilding can be based on shared responsibility rather than financial purchasing power; diplomacy rather than transactional politics; inclusion rather than exclusion; and measurable results rather than declarations, it could make a meaningful contribution.

Perhaps the real opportunity is not to build competing structures at all.

It is to bring together the best of American resources, European diplomacy, Arab regional knowledge, international financial institutions, Palestinian ownership and the legitimacy of the United Nations.

The world does not need another institution simply for the sake of creating one.

It needs a peace process that works.

And that requires something money alone cannot buy: political courage, experienced diplomacy, sustained commitment, accountability — and the determination to stay at the table until peace becomes more than a promise.

Dr Bilali Camara
Dr Bilali Camara
2 months ago

Board of Peace Trump or Board of Peace EU are both jokes as they will not solve anything for the Palestinians, only opportunities for Israel to commit more war crimes and genocide in Gaza and the West Bank!

Listen to \'The World\'s Toughest Job\' podcast

MOST POPULAR

1
Master of Science (M.S.) in Conflict and Security Analysis at Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations
Global Connections Television - The only talk show of its kind in the world

Understand the changing UN

 

Get PassBlue's award-winning reporting on the UN and global affairs.

Close the CTA